Slip & Fall
How to Choose a New York Slip and Fall Lawyer: Evidence, Fees, and Timing
Turn the fall into a premises-liability question
A New York slip and fall becomes a premises-liability question when you examine the condition that caused the fall, the property party that may be responsible, and the proof available to connect those facts. A property owner may be liable when it reasonably should have known about a hazard or defect that caused a slip and fall but failed to remedy it. If a store employee failed to fix a hazard, the business could be vicariously liable.
That possibility does not establish fault in your particular situation. The condition may have involved liquid, ice, an uneven surface, a defective stair, inadequate lighting, or another hazard, but the useful question is what happened, who controlled the area, and what the property party knew or reasonably should have known. A lawyer needs facts that can be tested rather than only a description of the injury.
The early record should identify the hazard, the location, and the people or organizations connected to the property. Investigate the hazard and gather evidence of notice, including maintenance logs or witness statements. Identify whether a private owner, municipality, or third-party contractor may be responsible.
Start with the details you can preserve: photographs of the condition, the exact location, the time of the fall, names of witnesses, an incident report, and communications with the owner, manager, insurer, or public agency. Maintenance records may show how the condition was handled, while witness information may help establish how long it existed or who knew about it. You do not need to decide the legal theory before gathering the facts.
A possible municipal property changes the timing question from the beginning.
The 90-day period concerns a claim governed by that law, not every fall on every type of property. If you fell on a public sidewalk, in a municipal building, or on other property connected with a public entity, identify that possibility promptly and obtain case-specific guidance. Treat property classification as a fact to investigate, not as a conclusion to guess.
Protect your health and the early record
Your immediate post-fall actions should protect your health while preserving basic information about what happened. For a New York City slip and fall, the recommended sequence includes the following:
- Report the accident to the property owner or manager and request an incident report.
- If possible, photograph the dangerous condition before it is repaired or removed.
- Get medical attention promptly, even if your injuries initially seem minor.
- Collect witness information and preserve relevant records.
If taking a photograph would put you at further risk, do not approach the hazard to create one. Ask someone who can do so safely, or record the location and condition as soon as practical.
Insurance communications deserve a deliberate response after a property injury. Avoid giving recorded statements to insurance companies before consulting an attorney. Preserve letters, emails, claim numbers, messages, and requests for statements instead of discarding them. An attorney can advise you about negotiating a settlement or moving forward with a lawsuit.
After you receive medical attention and gather evidence, contact an experienced slip and fall attorney as soon as possible. Prompt contact matters when a condition may be repaired, a witness may become difficult to locate, or a public-property deadline may apply.
New York property type affects the deadline analysis. A New York legal source states that accidents on government property have a 90-day Notice of Claim deadline and that private-property claims have a three-year statute of limitations.
Those time periods are not a substitute for reviewing your facts. The source describes different periods for government and private property, while the actual deadline can depend on the responsible party, the location, the claim, and other circumstances. Preserve the date of the fall and identify the property owner before assuming that a general period applies.

Bring a usable consultation file
Your consultation file should give a lawyer a clear timeline, a way to examine the hazard, and a starting point for identifying the responsible property party. Assemble what you have in a folder or digital file:
- Photographs or video of the surface, stair, sidewalk, lighting, ice, liquid, or other condition.
- The date, approximate time, exact location, and a short description of how the fall occurred.
- The incident report, property-management communications, and any messages or letters from an insurer.
- Names and contact information for witnesses, employees, managers, or people who helped after the fall.
- Medical records, bills, treatment information, work-related records, and notes about symptoms or limitations.
- Information showing who owned, occupied, managed, maintained, or controlled the area.
You may not have maintenance logs yourself, so record where they may exist and tell the lawyer who controlled the property.
Your written timeline should separate what you personally saw from what someone else told you. Note when you reported the condition, to whom you spoke, what response you received, and whether the condition changed afterward. Add the names of stores, landlords, contractors, municipalities, or other entities mentioned in documents.
Documentation of the full scope of damages may involve medical and financial experts. That does not mean you need to hire experts before a consultation. Bring the records you already have and identify missing information, such as treatment bills, wage records, or expenses related to the injury, so a lawyer can explain what may need further documentation.
Your questions can turn a stack of documents into a practical conversation. Ask what facts may show notice, which property party should be investigated, what records should be preserved, and what information is still missing. Ask how the lawyer would separate the condition itself from the question of who controlled the area.
Bring a short list rather than relying on memory. Include questions about the next procedural step, expected communication, insurance contact, evidence preservation, and the written fee agreement. A clear answer should tell you what happens next without promising that your claim will succeed.

Compare lawyers by premises fit and working relationship
Your comparison of New York slip and fall lawyers should focus on premises-liability fit rather than a general impression. Ask each lawyer or practice:
- How often do you handle slip, trip, and fall claims involving stores, landlords, sidewalks, stairs, or other property conditions?
- How do you investigate notice, maintenance, control of the area, and possible third-party responsibility?
- Do you handle claims involving private owners, businesses, municipalities, or contractors?
- Who will communicate with you, how will updates be provided, and how can you reach the legal team when a new document or insurer request arrives?
- What will the initial consultation cover, and what should you bring?
- What next step would follow if the lawyer believes the matter requires further review?
A lawyer who explains the condition, notice, responsible party, evidence, and timing in plain language gives you a more useful basis for choosing than a broad promise about results.
Bergman, Bergman, Fields & Lamonsoff, LLP represents victims of automobile, motorcycle, construction, slip, trip and fall accidents, and medical malpractice. For a property-injury consultation, ask how that experience applies to the facts of your fall, including the hazard, the property relationship, and the evidence that may establish notice.
Experience with other injury matters does not by itself answer the premises-liability questions in your case. The useful comparison is whether the lawyer can connect the relevant experience to your location, property type, evidence, and next procedural step.
Local access can matter when evidence, property records, witnesses, or medical information must be discussed in detail. We serve Queens, Brooklyn, the Bronx, and Manhattan from our Kew Gardens office. We serve Nassau, Suffolk, and all of Long Island from our Hicksville office.
Use office location as a practical question, not as a ranking by itself. Ask whether the legal team can work with the location of your fall, the property owner, and the available records. You should also understand who will handle communication if your matter involves more than one county or a public entity.
Early investigation should be part of your comparison. We emphasize the importance of early investigation because premises cases are won on early evidence. Ask what information the lawyer would seek first, how the condition and maintenance history might be documented, and how witnesses or responsible property parties would be identified.
Access also affects the practical working relationship. We provide home and hospital visits if you cannot travel. If travel is difficult, ask what consultation arrangement is available and what records you should have ready.
Ask how the fee becomes your cost
Your proposed retainer agreement should explain how the lawyer’s fee and case expenses affect the amount you may receive. Request the proposed retainer agreement and check that it identifies the attorney’s percentage, case expenses, disbursements, and each party’s responsibilities.
Ask for plain-language answers to these questions:
- What percentage is calculated as the attorney’s fee, and what amount is used as the base?
- Are litigation costs deducted before or after the fee is calculated?
- Who pays for expert witnesses, medical examinations, records, filing charges, and other disbursements?
- What happens to unpaid expenses if there is no recovery?
- Which New York contingency-fee schedule applies to the matter?
The written agreement controls the arrangement. Do not rely on a verbal description that leaves deductions or expenses unclear.
The percentage is only one part of the cost comparison. An ordinary contingency percentage is approximately 33% of the recovery, but your arrangement may be lower, follow a sliding scale, or depend on the matter and applicable rules. New York rules set contingency-fee schedules for personal injury cases, and the applicable schedule and your written fee agreement determine how the fee is calculated.
One New York contingency-fee schedule uses different percentages for different portions of the recovery; another cannot exceed 33⅓% of the recovery. Those descriptions concern different schedules, so ask which schedule and written terms apply to your proposed representation rather than assuming that one percentage applies to every case.
A sliding-scale arrangement can change the comparison at different recovery amounts. A New York fee analysis states that a court-rule sliding-scale alternative yields 36% of a $25,000 recovery. The same analysis states that the sliding scale costs the client more than one third below roughly $33,000 in recovery and costs the client less than one third above roughly $33,000 in recovery.
Those figures describe the fee comparison in that analysis; they do not identify the terms of every New York personal-injury agreement. Ask for the actual calculation in your proposed retainer, including the recovery amount used, the percentage applied to each portion, and the treatment of expenses.
A contingency arrangement usually shifts payment from the beginning of the matter to the recovery, but it does not make every possible cost disappear. In many qualifying cases, contingency-fee lawyers accept payment from the recovery rather than demanding a traditional upfront retainer. Under a standard contingency-fee arrangement, you generally do not owe an attorney’s fee if your lawyer obtains no compensation, but case expenses are a separate question.
Ask the expenses question directly. The answer should tell you whether unpaid costs remain your responsibility when there is no recovery, whether costs are advanced, and how medical or expert expenses are handled. Your goal is to understand the possible cost before you sign, not to predict the amount of any recovery.

Check the property type and timing immediately
Your property-type check should happen before you rely on a general deadline. Identify whether the location was privately owned, operated by a business, controlled by a municipality, or connected with another public entity or contractor. A slip-and-fall claim may require identifying whether a private owner, municipality, or third-party contractor may be responsible.
Contact qualified counsel promptly if the property type is uncertain or the fall happened on a sidewalk, in a public facility, or near property maintained by a public agency.
A New York municipal Notice of Claim has specific content and service requirements. The notice must be written, sworn before a notary, and include:
- The claimant and attorney information.
- The nature of the claim.
- When, where, and how the event arose, stated as precisely as possible.
- The claimed injuries or damages and dollar amount when practicable.
A New York municipal Notice of Claim must be served on the agency by personal delivery or registered or certified mail to a person authorized by law to receive service or to an attorney who regularly represents the public corporation. A report to a property employee or an insurance communication does not automatically answer whether a legally required notice was served in the required way.
Your lawsuit deadline is a separate question from the Notice of Claim deadline. Starting a lawsuit does not substitute for filing a required Notice of Claim, and failure to meet applicable notice requirements can make claims time barred. Even if a Notice of Claim was filed on time, a New York lawsuit generally must be started within one year and 90 days after the incident or event on which the claim is based.
A late notice is not automatically resolved by waiting. When deciding whether to allow a late Notice of Claim, a New York court may consider the government’s actual knowledge within the 90-day period, the claimant’s minority or incapacity, justifiable reliance on settlement discussions, an excusable mistake about the responsible government, and whether the delay substantially prejudiced the government’s defense. Those factors require case-specific review.
Recognize when prompt qualified help is especially important
Prompt qualified legal help matters when the facts could change or a deadline may already be running. Seek guidance promptly if any of these circumstances applies:
- The fall happened on property owned, controlled, or maintained by a municipality or another public entity.
- You are unsure who owned, occupied, managed, or maintained the area.
- The hazard has been repaired, removed, covered, or altered since the fall.
- Witnesses, photographs, maintenance records, or incident reports may be difficult to obtain.
- An insurer has asked you for a recorded statement or detailed account.
- Your injuries, treatment, work limitations, or expenses are continuing to develop.
These signs do not establish that you have a valid claim. They show why delaying the evidence and timing review can make your next decision harder.
Your first legal conversation should answer practical questions rather than promise a result. Ask what evidence should be preserved immediately, which property party may need investigation, whether a public-entity issue is present, what timing questions require review, and what communication will look like. Ask what the lawyer needs from you before the next step.
A clear explanation may still include uncertainty because responsibility, notice, property control, and deadlines depend on facts. That uncertainty is a reason to identify the missing facts and preserve the available record, not a reason to assume that every fall follows the same path.
Request the consultation with your questions ready
Your consultation checklist should cover four decisions: who may be responsible, what evidence should be preserved, how communication will work, and what the written fee agreement requires. Bring your timeline, photographs, reports, medical information, witness contacts, insurer communications, and property details. Ask which facts need immediate follow-up and which records may need to be requested.
Use the conversation to ask how the lawyer would explain the potential claim and next steps in language you understand. Ask how the property condition, notice, responsible party, timing, and costs fit together.
Bergman, Bergman, Fields & Lamonsoff, LLP offers free consultations for New York City injury victims to discuss potential compensation through a personal injury claim.
Bring the record you have and ask about responsibility, evidence, timing, and fees.
What should you confirm before choosing a New York slip and fall lawyer?
What should I bring to a New York slip and fall lawyer consultation?
Bring photographs or video of the condition, the date, time, and location of the fall, incident reports, property-owner or insurer communications, witness information, medical records and bills, work-related records, and details about who owned or controlled the area. A short timeline separating what you saw from what others told you can help identify missing evidence and possible responsible parties.
How should I compare New York slip and fall lawyers?
Ask about experience with premises-liability matters involving the relevant property type, investigation of notice and maintenance records, responsibility for public or private property, communication practices, and the next procedural step. Also ask who will handle your matter, how updates will be provided, what accessibility is available, and whether the lawyer explains uncertainty without promising a result.
What does a slip and fall lawyer cost in New York?
Many qualifying personal-injury matters use a contingency arrangement rather than a traditional upfront retainer. An ordinary contingency percentage is approximately 33%, but the arrangement may be lower, use a sliding scale, or depend on applicable rules and the written retainer. Case expenses are separate, so ask whether they are deducted before or after the fee, who pays them, and what happens to unpaid expenses if there is no recovery.
What happens if there is no recovery in a New York slip and fall case?
Under a standard contingency-fee arrangement, you generally do not owe an attorney’s fee if the lawyer obtains no compensation. Case expenses are a separate issue, however, so review the retainer to determine whether you may remain responsible for records, experts, medical examinations, filing charges, or other disbursements.
Does a fall on public property have a different deadline in New York?
It may. Starting a lawsuit does not substitute for that notice, and even a timely notice does not eliminate the need to review the separate lawsuit deadline. Property ownership, location, and claim circumstances require prompt case-specific legal review.
What should I do if the dangerous condition has already been repaired?
Preserve the photographs, videos, incident reports, witness contacts, communications, medical records, and timeline you already have, and note when you learned the condition changed. Tell a lawyer promptly because maintenance records, witness accounts, and other evidence may help document what existed and who controlled the area. Do not put yourself at risk to recreate the condition.
Keep reading
More on Slip & Fall
Slip & Fall
Slip and Fall Injury: What to Do After a Fall in New York
Learn what to do after a slip and fall injury in New York, when to seek care, preserve evidence, and consider legal review.
Read article
Slip & Fall
Slip and Fall Attorney Los Angeles: How to Prepare for a Consultation and Compare Your Options
Prepare for a Los Angeles slip-and-fall consultation by organizing evidence, checking timing, comparing attorneys, and understanding fees.
Read article
Slip & Fall
How to Choose a New York Trip and Fall Attorney: A Consultation Decision Guide
Learn how to choose a New York trip and fall attorney, preserve evidence, compare fees, and prepare for a focused consultation.
Read articleHurt like this?
Tell us what happened.
We handle Slip & Fall cases across Long Island, Queens and New York City. The consultation is free and you pay nothing unless we win.
- Answered 24/7
- No fee unless we win
- Hablamos español
Send us the details
Takes about a minute. Free and confidential.